Such an investigation of the Iraq war is long overdue. He sought to reverse the gradual decline in the defense budget and to build up U. When asked at the time why U. Both McNamara and Rumsfeld were described repeatedly by their contemporaries as brilliant. Supposedly I had been sent to see Saddam by President Reagan either to negotiate a secret oil deal, to help arm Iraq, or to make Iraq an American client state.
As Secretary of Defense, both men came to dominate their presidents and feed on their weaknesses. Both dominated the national security debate, silencing critics within the administration and ignoring generals in the field.
Fortunately the administration resisted that pressure.
Because the notion that there may be more to Rumsfeld than meets the eye — that somewhere deep inside he must experience conflict, doubt, or at least a sense of responsibility — is the optimistic view.
Since his departure from active duty, Shinseki has kept his own counsel. In the long term, it would only exacerbate the underlying problem. An editorial in the Economist called for him to resign; Rumsfeld now says he regrets he did not 'insist' on doing so.
Rumsfeld dictated a four-page response to Anderson, labeling the accusations as falsehoods, and invited Anderson to tour his office. Like Rumsfeld, McNamara was certain that Americans were liberators and not imperialists. I had no idea if Iraq was or was not involved, but it would have been irresponsible for any administration not to have asked the question.
Gordon and Trainor wrote: The United States wished for the conflict to end, and Rumsfeld was sent to the Middle East to serve as a mediator on behalf of the President.
Supposedly I had been sent to see Saddam by President Reagan either to negotiate a secret oil deal, to help arm Iraq, or to make Iraq an American client state.
So in the early Eighties he found work as a private detective, unhindered by a lack of training. And it offers a model of true military professionalism as well. It was a time of discovery—of seeking elusive, imperfect solutions for new problems that would not be solved quickly.
Both McNamara and Rumsfeld were described repeatedly by their contemporaries as brilliant. A leader in broadband transmission, distribution, and access control technologies for cable, satellite and terrestrial broadcasting applications, the company pioneered the development of the first all-digital high-definition television HDTV technology.
In addition, he was asked to serve the U. He was also a member of the U. That may be all there is.Donald Rumsfeld was the second longest-serving US secretary of defense after Robert McNamara, another manager of a disastrous war.
By Mark Feeney Globe Staff April 03, The most important is that McNamara was an abject failure in office and Rumsfeld was not. Under Rumsfeld, our military liberated two nations and both remain liberated, though troubled. Under McNamara, we lost ground and moved well.
McNamara and Rumsfeld also had the same ideology, thinking that American’s were liberators. We will write a custom essay sample on Was Donald Rumsfeld Robert Mcnamara Reborn specifically for you. There are some parallels in the careers Donald Rumsfeld and Robert McNamara, both high-profile secretaries of defense.
Both men presided over controversial wars, and both were replaced as those. Mar 25, · DONALD RUMSFELD: Reports that say that something hasn’t happened are always interesting to me, because as we know, there are known knowns; there are things we know we know.
We also know there are known unknowns; that is to say we know there are some things we do not know. As its subtitle suggests, one reason Errol Morris' documentary, The Fog of War: Eleven Lessons From the Life of Robert S. McNamara, proved so resonant is that its subject was partly a proxy.Download